Hernandez reasoned you to definitely mere court sanction of a sexual connection could not the only real evidence that a person is a genuine and you can moral citizen
In some way my personal proposition goes resistant to the very first and basic place out-of relationships, but regardless of if we’re and only marriage, as well as suitable of males which generate legislation for all those, we wish to silently think man’s real situation. Considering you to laws derives away from reality, these types of people have united right here to type a composition and therefore wipes brush the fresh new problems of history and seeks a different road for future years, [thus] it is important that they judiciously studies the latest criteria your landscape and come to the finish there are some thing into the our lives along with our society that we can’t inside in whatever way close our very own vision, that individuals must face valiantly. 51
From the asserting one to a disjuncture existed between legislators’ ideals and you may “public reality,” Hernandez debated you to she try attacking to have Cubans have been maybe not aren’t considered different types of intimate propriety and you will, therefore, had been unjustly disenfranchised
I have arrive at this new Construction so you can sparingly defend, to the best of my personal feature, the Cuban lady, new married woman, the new single woman, the new light lady, the black lady, women of all of the kinds. I need to say that there is a large number of Cuban women in hard and you will awkward affairs, that happen to be just like the respectable so that as worthy of quality as the was most other ladies, that simply as the she actually is during the a totally free partnership, does not mean that we should consider the woman along with her friends depraved. 52
Twenty-several outside of the 60-half dozen Assembly members going to the example voted to approve Hernandez’s proposal. A lot of people that chosen within the like reasoned that it do oblige men inside the consensual unions to meet up with a comparable requirements and you will obligations that married people had been destined to see and you may, thus, perform manage every woman and children. Such as, progressive Installation representative Capablanca argued you to definitely “though it [Hernandez’s amendment] looks paradoxical, far from being…a strike into wedding, it is actually a safeguards from it.” 53 The guy told me, “When males be aware that he is guilty of female which have exactly who he’s good consensual connection and for the pupils you to http://datingmentor.org/escort/winston-salem/ definitely results from these 100 % free unions, they will not participate in consensual unions in matrimony.” 54 Capablanca portrayed people because the almost inherently irresponsible, and you may meant that ladies called for Condition defense against her or him. Anybody else echoed his rationale.
Although not, many Installation users, progressives and you will traditionals, balked on Hernandez’s suggestion, arguing it was not conducive so you’re able to popular improvements and create grant legal rights and you may privileges so you can undeserving, depraved customers. Antique Set up user Cortina contributed an excellent saturated fight against Hernandez’s suggestion, creating his dissent once the a battle having modernity, progress, and you will civilization. He mentioned that an effective constitutional guarantee to adopt consensual unions similar to help you court marriage ceremonies manage generally post Cuba out of with the an appropriate highway divergent of compared to “the gentle nations on the planet” and “ruin…the latest matrimonial system, and make [it] totally useless.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “If this modification were acknowledged, we might build a large distress in the court marriage, and then we do use the consequences of your own governmental revolution which i’ve just stayed because of, to groups in our sentimental and you can relatives lifetime, [sectors] and that don’t have to feel transformed regarding the radical and you may perturbing way that are proposed.” 56 To possess Cortina, the fresh 1933 revolution is actually a governmental revolution, and subsequent change should only affect government: Social points are leftover by yourself.